Converting a leasehold property into a freehold property improves title of asset; holding period reckoned from date of lease

Conversion of rights of lessee in property from leasehold right into freehold right only results in improvement of his or her rights over property and it would not have any effect on taxability of gain from such property, which is related to period over which property is held

Facts:

a) The assessee purchased a property on leasehold basis in year 1984. She got said property converted into freehold property in year 2004 and thereupon sold it. The capital gain arising therefrom was declared by assessee as long-term capital gain (‘LTCG’);

b) The Assessing Officer held that since the property was acquired by converting the leasehold right into freehold right and was sold within three years, gain arising thereform was taxable as short-term capital gain;

c) On appeal, the CIT(A) held that capital gain arising from sale of such property was to be taxed as LTCG. Further, the Tribunal upheld the order of the CIT (A). The aggrieved revenue filed the instant appeal.

The High Court held in favour of assessee as under:

1) The difference between the 'short-term capital asset' and 'long-term capital asset' was the period over which the property had been held by the assessee and not the nature of title over the property;

2) The conversion of the rights of the lessee in the property from having leasehold right into freehold right was only by way of improvement of her rights over the property and it would not have any effect on the taxability of gain arising from such property, which was related to the period over which the property was held by assessee;

3) In the present case, the property was held by the assessee as a lessee since 1984, and the same was transferred on 31.3.2004, (i.e. after holding it for more than three years) after the leasehold rights were converted into freehold rights on the same property which was in her possession. Thus, gain arising from such property would be taxable as LTCG - CIT V. SMT. RAMA RANI KALIA (2013) 38 taxman 176 (Allahabad)